Umm hmm in my opinion the older ones are fun by older I mean not the tamag go but not the P1 like Tamagothci Connections 1-4.5, I have a V4.5 a V4, and a V3, getting a new V4.5. anyways I love most out of all of them... I think it would be my V4 but only cuz I have had my V4.5 forever. The V3 is fun but the games are kinda hard for me. The v4 has many characters and the Universal characters are the ones you dont want unlike in the V4.5 I mean who doesn't want a mametchi, for me I can't get one on my V4.5, but on the V4 I can get it. For beginers if maybe you forgot about tamagotchis however I would reccomend the V4.5 as it is easier to take care of, less time consuming simply feed it and play with it so its not fat and its happy and it'll be fine. I mean you have to do the same in the V4 but its not as easy. The V4.5s games are easiest in my opinion. I heard the ID L is great but its like 50 USD so its expensive, not an impulse buy. Anyways this is completely random but I love runescape maybe we could go dungoneering sometime.