Marilyn Manson VS P!ATD

[Self:.:Pity]

Ever heard of the song "this is Halloween" For the Nightmare before Christmas? Both of them redid the song in their own way, and there's a thing on which one is better. Who do you think?

//www.tamatalk.com/IB/applications/core/interface/js/spacer.png
P!ATD

And this is the original version

I personally say MM. Its just so much more awesome now ^.^

 

[~TamaBloom12~]

MM, definitely alot better, I kinda like that song

 

[Robonekro]

MM's version is WAY better

he made the song even scarier ^ ^

~BB

 

[MsKtty89]

Oh, hello! MANSON MANSON MANSON!

I'm a big fan of him, though. I'm getting all excited now, I like his version of this more than the original even.

...I almost saw him in concert, but my friends got to go and I didn't (I was broke). Someday!

 

[Self:.:Pity]

Ha ha. I love MM...

Dont get me wrong, I love P!ATD, but they..they just made it so plain and stuff. His made it actually scary, and im glad people agree with me!

 

[pyonchit]

Meh, I don't really know. I do like both, although I think that P!ATD did a better job with keeping the more original... feel..

I'm not a big fan of "remakes" though, so maybe it's just me.

 

[tamaw/pants]

I don't like Marilyn or Panic! very much to begin with. Although, I really did like Manson's redo alot better. ;]

 

[Jinx3295]

yeah.. Marilyn Manson took it and made it REALLY scary and cooler xD

Panic!'s is pretty good.. but Marilyn Manson wins for sure.

 

[mimitchis_rock13579]

Neither. I'm more into Queen, Green Day, Evanescence, and Siouxsie and the Banshees. But I do like Marilyn Manson's song "The Beautiful People"

 

[**UrItChI**]

I don't like Marilyn or Panic! very much to begin with. Although, I really did like Manson's redo alot better. ;]

I completely agree with you, TM/P.