I think aquapets are also cute, but tamagotchis have a LOT more options and not to mention characters! So of course, being a big fan of tamagotchis, I would choose tamagotchis.
tamas all the way! aqua pets just "swim" around and make annoying noises! Plus, my sis neglected hers for a few months, and the water turned the color of pee! ewww
tamagotchi is WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY better because aquapets r annoying!!! they won't stop making noise and i can't figure it out because i lost the instructions. and the only way to shut it up is 2 yank out the batteries.
Tamas all the way are so much better. I bought my Spongebob and Patrick Aquapets just for collectability and they were on clearance at Walmart for $3.00. Also, what water 42 said in their last post; they are now discontinued for that obvious reason.